Showing posts with label scholes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label scholes. Show all posts

Monday, 6 October 2014

ADMIRE RONALDO MASTERY BUT IGNORE TALK OF COMPLETENESS

Former Spain international Marcelino is the latest to heap praise on the magnificent Portuguese by calling him "the most complete player in the history of football". Amazing as Ronaldo is, this praise does not offer a true reflection of what he brings to the ballpark.


D. Ray Morton, 6th October 2014.

Cristiano Ronaldo made the amazing seem routine again last night with yet another Liga trifecta, this time against Basque side Athletic

Cristiano Ronaldo was on fire again last night as Real Madrid thrashed Athletic Bilbao 5-0 at the Santiago Bernabéu with their main man netting another hat-trick to make it a remarkable 13 goals in 6 Liga appearances this season so far. Former Newcastle United and Spain centre-half, Marcelino, was the latest to heap admiration on CR7 stating that he is the most complete player in the history of football.

Ronaldo is indeed incredible. As an attacking force, there are few things he does not do perfectly. His athleticism is unquestionable and he has one of the strongest mentalities in the modern game in terms of always seeking perfection and bettering himself. There is, however, a pitfall when you refer to Ronaldo as being "complete" and it actually takes away from realising what he does best.

There is an old tale about Ronaldo's time at Manchester United. Showing off his latest trick to the lads in training, a wily Paul Scholes watched on in amusement. Ronaldo had, perhaps, just demonstrated a flashy step-over or an incredible juggling act to Scholes and co. and the old, red-headed midfield conductor decided to teach the young pup a lesson. Spotting a set of long distance targets at least forty yards away, Scholes proceeded to plant three lofted passes precisely onto each. Ronaldo's jaw dropped in amazement as it was something he could not replicate and probably still could not to this day.

Paul Scholes, a former teammate of Ronaldo's, could dictate the midfield tempo and pick a pass the way the Portuguese can not
 
This is no criticism of Ronaldo as his position on the pitch these days usually does not require such an attribute but it does indicate that there are players who can do things he simply does not and can not do. This is the beauty of football. If you are to argue that a player is complete, should that not mean he can play in every outfield position on the pitch à la ex-Barcelona (now manager) and Spain's Luis Enrique? Should it mean that they have every attribute a footballer needs at an on-average higher level than everyone else? And yes, that does include tackling.

Ronaldo, more accurately, could be described as the most complete attacking player of all-time though there are those who might argue that legendary Dutchman Marco van Basten or Brazil's Ronaldo, El Fenómino, deserve that recognition. There are attackers with better positioning than CR7 and there are definitely players with much higher work-rate, aggression and the ability to sacrifice themselves for their team-mates. A player like Luis Suárez, who joined Liga rivals Barcelona this season, demonstrates that level of ruthless doggishness which Cristiano does not. Can he weave through those tiny spaces like Lionel Messi? Does Ronaldo have the characteristics, for example, to really improve the players around him in the Portuguese national team? Recent World Cup evidence suggests not so much though his overloaded schedule last season is worth considering when making that judgement.

So let us drop these silly remarks about who is the most complete in the history of football because the point does not make a whole lot of sense. Admire this incredible player for what he brings and do not dwell on the idea of "completeness" because as fallible humans, no-one is complete.

Thursday, 30 January 2014

MATA SIGNING MORE A DECOY THAN A COUP

David Moyes has often repeated the need for the Premier League champions to rebuild this year despite inheriting a squad that very easily cruised to the title last season. Juan Mata represents the first part of that rebuilding process, their only other prior signing of note being Marouane Fellaini who could easily be crowned the worst transfer of the season by the time all is said and done.

Talented, but will he ever gain the legendary status of a Keane or Scholes?



Mata represents a marriage of convenience to United. Clearly not rated by Jose Mourinho, his quick transfer to Manchester is something we might see a lot more of in years to come. Super-rich clubs like Chelsea and Manchester City will build strong squads full of quality players with different sets of attributes in order to give themselves the variety and rotation potential needed to challenge on all fronts. Occasionally, a player like Mata will slip through the cracks. Clearly talented but perhaps not talented enough to be deemed unsellable by Mourinho, United have acquired an intelligent attacking midfielder who can play in a variety of positions but not exactly the positions they need strengthening in right now.



The major problems remain in the heart of defence with veterans Nemaja Vidic and Rio Ferdinand declining rapidly whilst the trio of Chris Smalling, Jonny Evans and Phil Jones still carry big question marks with them. Left-back is another problem area with Patrice Evra's downturn and the central midfield conundrum still exists years after United should have signed a world class enforcer or pass-master to ease their fans' yearnings for the likes of a new Roy Keane or a Paul Scholes.



What might be of higher concern for United fans is their style of play this season. It is easy to pick apart personnel when the team is not playing well in general but good morale and confidence can make typically useful players seem even more functional and effective. A player like Michael Carrick can appear mediocre when the team is struggling but last season, many United fans argued that he was their unsung hero. Alex Ferguson had this huge motivational aura thanks to decades of collecting trophies. Moyes does not have this aura about him so any success he might have will be built on patience and assembling better players. Whether he can offer anything tactically is a big if. Moyes' teams at Everton could be threatening at times but they often had an agricultural feel about them and may have been seeking away draws, an attitude which just won't do at a club as huge and as ambitious as Manchester United. There is a lot of work to be done but Moyes has a lot of time to get this right. Regardless of where they finish this season, expect the red-haired Scot to be in the dug-out at the beginning of the 2014/15 campaign. If they get off to a bad start, only then can the #MoyesOut brigade expect to get what they want.

D. Ray Morton, 30 Jan 2014