The Republic of Ireland sank to a disappointing 1-0 defeat away to Scotland to fall down to fourth place in UEFA Euro 2016 qualifying Group D. Can they pick themselves up and get vengeance against the Scots at the Aviva next June?
D. Ray Morton, 17th November 2014.
Shaun Maloney celebrates the goal that shattered Ireland's dreams in Glasgow
Scotland put the Republic of Ireland to the sword at Celtic Park on Friday night thanks to a finely-worked late winner from Shaun Maloney to spell trouble for Martin O'Neill's men early in this European Championship qualifying group. Speculation before the game had centred on the Republic's Glasgow-born duo, Aiden McGeady and James McCarthy, with the ex-Scottish international Gordon McQueen hoping the Parkhead crowd would give them a "horrible reception" for choosing to play for an international team they were not born in. McCarthy pulled out with an injury and McGeady started but it did not seem as if he was targeted for any special treatment on the night.
If there was anything focused on McGeady, it was drowned out by what was a raucous atmosphere in general. Any player in possession, Irish or Scottish, felt bellowing roars from the rafters of one of Europe's most intimidating arenas. This lead to a somewhat disjointed and quite ugly game of football. Possession was gifted cheaply, especially by Ireland with their overall completed passes actually being less than that against Germany in a game which they snatched a point despite a barrage of German attacks. There is such a thing as playing with passion but there is also playing with recklessness and Ireland certainly achieved both on this occasion.
Their play resembled that of a scrappy rugby team. They got stuck in and the challenges were wild. There was no intelligence to their play. The missing pair of the aforementioned McCarthy and Wes Hoolahan hit Ireland hard. Without their bit of craft of the ball, the Irish resorted back to Trappatoni-esque tactics of aimless long ball for the most part. Robbie Keane had been dropped in favour of starting Shane Long as a lone target man but the gamble failed.
If there was anything focused on McGeady, it was drowned out by what was a raucous atmosphere in general. Any player in possession, Irish or Scottish, felt bellowing roars from the rafters of one of Europe's most intimidating arenas. This lead to a somewhat disjointed and quite ugly game of football. Possession was gifted cheaply, especially by Ireland with their overall completed passes actually being less than that against Germany in a game which they snatched a point despite a barrage of German attacks. There is such a thing as playing with passion but there is also playing with recklessness and Ireland certainly achieved both on this occasion.
Their play resembled that of a scrappy rugby team. They got stuck in and the challenges were wild. There was no intelligence to their play. The missing pair of the aforementioned McCarthy and Wes Hoolahan hit Ireland hard. Without their bit of craft of the ball, the Irish resorted back to Trappatoni-esque tactics of aimless long ball for the most part. Robbie Keane had been dropped in favour of starting Shane Long as a lone target man but the gamble failed.
Stephen Quinn was supposed to be Ireland's "plan B" off the bench but his performance typified his side's reckless play and was lucky not to be sent off on the night
In RTÉ's analysis of the match, pundit Richie Sadlier had rightly suggested that Ireland's gameplan had been focused on effort over skill. Liam Brady felt they had been outplayed by what was, on paper, a slightly weaker team and that it showed Scottish manager Gordon Strachan had won the tactical battle.
O'Neill's post-match interviews deflected the focus on their rematch at the Aviva next summer. He gets off lightly because Ireland have made a good start all things considered. No-one expected Ireland to draw in Germany and their points total is probably acceptable. The manner of play is another story. O'Neill will be forgiven if he can turn it around in Dublin but until then, the sceptics will be sharpening their knives.
Former Manchester United manager Sir Alex Ferguson heads a panel of "elite coaches" which give UEFA recommendations for changing rules in their continental competitions. Considering some of his decisions outside of actual football management, is he the right man for this role
Gone from the game, or is he? Ferguson is still manipulating the football world despite retiring as a manager a year and a half ago
He was the man that brought David Moyes to Manchester United sinking them into mid-table obscurity and now he leads a panel that recommends changes in UEFA rules that will directly effect the European Champions League. His recommendations seem to be based on personal dissatisfactions with the rules and do not reflect what is best to bring the game forward.
One of his recommendations is to change rules in the Champions League which sees players suspended from the final. He has experienced this in his own managerial career having lost Paul Scholes and Roy Keane for United's clash with Bayern Munich in Barcelona is 1999 and with Darren Fletcher for the tie against Chelsea in 2009. The rules probably do need sprucing up but it is somewhat disconcerting that these changes would be made only because the retired Scottish managerial legend kicks up a fuss about it. Teams, players and managers have had the same problems with the rules for years, just ask Xabi Alonso who missed the showcase final last season, but does this mean UEFA will only listen when it is the likes of Ferguson speaking up about it?
He has also suggested a ludicrous "sin-bin" system borrowed out of rugby which could cause a huge amount of confusion and tactical cynicism. As the current rules stand, a red card means a player's involvement in the game is over. A sin-bin system could involve calculated fouls designed so the punishment only lasts a set amount of time. One imagines a shrewd manager with a dark side could use such a rule deviously.
Alex Ferguson's post-managerial decisions in football have been poor. He is a legend of the game but he needs to step away from it as he only seeks controversy, more praise and more recognition. His presence at Old Trafford last season was an uncomfortable one and never gave David Moyes a chance to breathe. This season, despite Louis van Gaal's shaky start, there is a greater sense of ease around the club without old purple nose behind his back. This feels like a clean slate and it allows for optimism. Walk off into the sunset, Fergie, before you start to ruin your great legacy.
One of his recommendations is to change rules in the Champions League which sees players suspended from the final. He has experienced this in his own managerial career having lost Paul Scholes and Roy Keane for United's clash with Bayern Munich in Barcelona is 1999 and with Darren Fletcher for the tie against Chelsea in 2009. The rules probably do need sprucing up but it is somewhat disconcerting that these changes would be made only because the retired Scottish managerial legend kicks up a fuss about it. Teams, players and managers have had the same problems with the rules for years, just ask Xabi Alonso who missed the showcase final last season, but does this mean UEFA will only listen when it is the likes of Ferguson speaking up about it?
He has also suggested a ludicrous "sin-bin" system borrowed out of rugby which could cause a huge amount of confusion and tactical cynicism. As the current rules stand, a red card means a player's involvement in the game is over. A sin-bin system could involve calculated fouls designed so the punishment only lasts a set amount of time. One imagines a shrewd manager with a dark side could use such a rule deviously.
Alex Ferguson's post-managerial decisions in football have been poor. He is a legend of the game but he needs to step away from it as he only seeks controversy, more praise and more recognition. His presence at Old Trafford last season was an uncomfortable one and never gave David Moyes a chance to breathe. This season, despite Louis van Gaal's shaky start, there is a greater sense of ease around the club without old purple nose behind his back. This feels like a clean slate and it allows for optimism. Walk off into the sunset, Fergie, before you start to ruin your great legacy.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Let us know what you think